Ice Cream Social
About Ice Cream Social
Ice Cream Social brings all-vegan frozen yogurt shop and ice cream shop dishes to Commack's dining scene. Guests give it 4.3 stars over 164 reviews, and prices are mid-range. With a casual and trendy atmosphere, it's popular with groups, and offers curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout.
Amenities & Offerings
Ice Cream Social FAQ
Is Ice Cream Social fully vegan?
Yes. Ice Cream Social is a 100% vegan restaurant, so everything on the menu is plant-based.
What food does Ice Cream Social serve?
Ice Cream Social serves ice cream shop · frozen yogurt shop, generally priced around $$. See the full menu on their website or in person.
Does Ice Cream Social offer delivery or takeout?
Yes. Ice Cream Social offers delivery and takeout. Availability can vary, so check before you order.
What are Ice Cream Social's hours?
Today Ice Cream Social is open 12-10PM. Full weekly hours are listed on this page and can change on holidays.
Where is Ice Cream Social located?
Ice Cream Social is at 1153 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725. Use “Get directions” on this page for a map and driving directions.
Where can I see the menu for Ice Cream Social?
View Ice Cream Social's menu on their website (www.icecreamsocialli.com) or on their Google Business listing linked on this page.
Listing information updated September 2026.
Ice Cream Social Reviews
J Rose
Google Reviews
Love Ice Cream Social Commack! Generous portions, fantastic cakes and overall amazing products!!! The kids love it! Would definitely recommend!
F K
Google Reviews
$10.50 for a medium soft serve with sprinkles? Edited: Sorry, but no. Lics and Mickey's are dirt cheap by comparison. Look further, the solo ice cream spots in Port Jeff, Miller Place and Riverhead don't come close. You're overpriced. Period.
Pat Lowes
Google Reviews
Waaaaaaay too expensive. Won’t be coming back :(((
Scott Cackett
Google Reviews
The owner makes me horny ......
Jenny Maldonado
Google Reviews
The flavors are so delicious. However, the price is not worth what you get. They’re very stingy with the scoops. I don’t mind paying +$12 for a waffle bowl but I’d be satisfied if it was filled with the amount of ice cream it can hold.
MEWilke MEWilke
Google Reviews
The flavors are super creative and the quality is super rich in this locally owned spot run by a chef! The flavors change regularly and everything is home made. My favorite is the pumpkin Oreo. They also have boozy eggnog, coconut chip, Mexican hot chocolate. The only thing I wish for is some tables to sit at.
Alex Garcia
Google Reviews
It was my first time there. I live in Commack but someone in Hauppague recommended this place. They have a lot of standard flavors and seasonal flavors. They also have a separate section for vegan flavors. We ended up getting two shakes one was a Chocolate pumpkin shake and the other was a Rainbow Cookie malt shake. Both were probably some of the best shakes I’ve ever had. I’m a big shake guy so I’m not easily impressed.
Family SV
Google Reviews
The ice cream here is absolutely delicious! We’ve ordered two birthday cakes from them. The artistry was stunning! You can taste the quality of the ingredients and the fact that it is homemade! Service is always friendly! Whether at the main shop or at a pop up. It is owned and operated by a local family too!
Anonymous
Google Reviews
The ice cream is very good however two single scoop cups should not cost $14. And then they have the audacity to put tip cups by the register. For those prices they should be paying their employees better. Refuse to pay those prices so I won’t be returning.
Ian Winkler
Google Reviews
The ice cream is great! Great tasting and too many choices 😄. Friendly, helpful staff. I'll be back!